Go to content

Comments in receipt order

In accordance with the Electoral Act 2017, comments on suggestions lodged with the Electoral Districts Redistribution Panel are made available for public inspection on the Electoral Commission’s website.

The below comments were lodged during the comments period 2–15 July 2020. 

The documents on this page have been provided by members of the public and have not been checked for compliance with the World Wide Web Consortium's Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.0. If you experience any issues accessing the documents on this page, please contact the Secretariat of the Electoral Districts Redistribution Panel at redistribution@elections.nsw.gov.au. All comments are in PDF format; the file sizes range from 0.1MB to 8MB.

Comment reference number

District(s)/Locality

Name

Documents

Related suggestion

NSWR200706/42

Canterbury

D Markou - Belmore 2192 and Surrounding Streets of Canterbury Hospital

Document A

NSWR200608/2




Document B

NSWR200618/4




Document C

NSWR200630/27




Document D

NSWR200701/34




Document E

NSWR200701/35




Document F

NSWR200701/36




Document G

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200706/43

Upper Hunter region

J Doyle 

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200629/44

Riverstone / Marsden Park

F Marciani 

Comment

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200707/45

Riverstone / Marsden Park

I Chajju 

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200707/46

Barwon, Murray

J Bushell

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR2007070/47

Riverstone / Marsden Park

S Yang 

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR200709/48

Whole-Of-State

Comment has been withdrawn at the request of the commenter.



NSWR200711/49

Whole-Of-State

M Gordon

Comment

NSWR200618/4, NSWR200630/26, 
NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35,  NSWR200701/36,
NSWR200701/38, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200712/50

Upper Hunter

H Schütze

Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200710/51

Wagga Wagga

Lockhart Shire Council

Comment

NSWR200616/3

NSWR200713/52

Campbelltown, Appin

D Meznaric 

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200713/53

Upper Hunter

L Doyle - Olinda Community Association

Map
Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200713/54

Cootamundra

Narrandera Shire Council

Comment

NSWR200605/1, NSWR200618/4,
NSWR200630/24, NSWR200630/28, 
NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/37,
NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/35,
NSWR200701/38, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200713/55

Sydney

A Greenwich Independent Member for Sydney

Comment

NSWR200608/2, NSWR200618/4, 
NSW200630/25, NSWR200701/34,  
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/36,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200713/56

Upper Hunter, Tamworth, Liverpool Plains LGA

J Maunder 

Comment

NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200713/57

Cabramatta

D Le

Map
Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200713/58

Western NSW

F Pietroboni

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200713/59

Appin, Campbelltown, Wollondilly

R Baxter

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200713/60

Upper Hunter

A Driver and R Mach 

Document 1
Document 2

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200713/61

Upper Hunter

B Traynor 

Comments

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200713/62

Heathcote / Keira

M Jones

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200713/63

Cabramatta

F Carbone 

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200713/64

Cabramatta, Fairfield, Liverpool

F Carbone 

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200714/65

Sydney

P Calligeros

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200714/66

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

P Meurer and S Meurer

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200714/67

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

S Robinson 

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200714/68

Monaro

Queanbeyan-Palerang Regional Council

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR200714/69

Hornsby

J Inshaw

Comment

NSWR200626/9, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200714/70

Port Stephens

J McInerney

Comment

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/35
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200714/71

Cabramatta

D Le

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200714/72

Tamworth

M Rodda

Comment

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/35
NSWR200701/36, NSWR200701/38

NSWR200714/73

Port Stephens

L Lane

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200714/74

Barwon

Shooters, Fishers and Farmers Party (NSW) Incorporated

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR200714/75

Davidson

R Wood

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200714/76

Wagga Wagga/Lockhart Shire

T Driscoll - The Rock Progress Association

Comment

NSWR200616/3

NSWR200714/77

Heathcote, Holsworthy and Miranda

M Bail 

Comment

NSWR200629/12, NSWR200629/13
NSWR200629/14, NSWR200629/15,
NSWR200629/16

NSWR200714/78

Port Stephens

M Flood

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200714/79

Cootamundra

M Payne

Comment

NSWR200629/18, NSWR200630/28
NSWR200701/37

NSWR200714/80

Whole-Of-State

N Weston

Comment

NSWR200608/2, NSWR200618/4,
NSWR200626/7, NSWR200629/11,
NSWR200629/12, NSWR200629/13,
NSWR200629/14, NSWR200629/15,
NSWR200629/16, NSWR200629/17,
NSWR200629/19, NSWR200630/20,
NSWR200630/23, NSWR200630/25,
NSWR200630/26, NSWR200701/30,
NSWR200701/33, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/36,
NSWR200701/39, NSWR200701/40,
NSWR200701/41

NSWR200715/81

Barwon/Lachlan Shire

Lachlan Shire Council 

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/82

Whole-of-State

The Greens NSW

Comment

NSWR200628/10, NSWR200629/18,
NSWR200630/22, NSWR200630/23,
NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/38,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/83

Port Stephens

N Waters - Port Stephens Greens

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/84

Cootamundra

D Fahey 

Comment

NSWR200605/1

NSWR200715/85

Ku-ring-gai, Wakehurst

M Brown

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200715/86

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

R Johnston

Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200715/87

Port Stephens

G Washington

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/88

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

P Monaghan

Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200715/89

Riverstone

S Lawrence - Riverstone Schofields and Districts Chamber of Commerce and Industry

Comment

NSWR200608/2, NSWR200618/4,
NSWR200626/9, NSWR200630/22,
NSWR200630/25, NSWR200630/27, 
NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/36,
NSWR200701/39,

NSWR200715/90

Whole-of-State

National Party of Australia – NSW

Comment

NSWR200605/1,NSWR200608/2,
NSWR200616/3, NSWR200618/4,
NSWR200622/5, NSWR200626/8,
NSWR200628/18, NSWR200630/21,
NSWR200630/22, NSWR200630/24,
NSWR200630/28, NSWR200701/30,
NSWR200701/31, NSWR200701/32,
NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/36 ,
NSWR200701/37, NSWR200701/38

NSWR200715/91

Port Stephens, Upper Hunter

B van der Wijngaart

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/92

Fairfield, Cabramatta, Liverpool, Granville

K Chapman

Comment

NSWR200608/2

NSWR200715/93

Murray, Barwon

D Burton

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR200715/94

Port Stephens

G Piper MP for Lake Macquarie 

Comment

NSWR200701/30, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/95

Campbelltown, Wollondilly / Appin

D D’Arcy

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/96

Campbelltown, Wollondilly / Appin

A D’Arcy

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/97

Cootamundra/Cowra Shire

Cr Bill West, Mayor Cowra Council

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200713/98

Port Stephens / Gloucester

M Blanch

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/99

Western NSW

A Quarisa - Griffith Business Chamber

Comment

Not specified

NSWR200715/100

Wagga Wagga

J McGirr MP, Member for Wagga Wagga

Comment 

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/35,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/101

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

J Fuller

Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200715/102

Camden

L Stratton - Camden Historical Society

Comment

NSWR200630/26, NSWR200701/33,
NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/35,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/103

Port Stephens

M Wilkinson

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/104

Clarence, Lismore

Richmond Valley Council

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/105

Clarence, Lismore

Richmond Valley Council

Comment

NSWR200701/35

NSWR200715/106

Clarence, Lismore

Richmond Valley Council

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/107

Whole-of-State

The Liberal Party of Australia, New South Wales Division

Comment

NSWR200701/35, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/108

Cootamundra / Leeton Shire, Narrandera

J Clark

Comment

NSWR200605/1, NSWR200628/18,
NSWR200630/24, NSWR200630/28

NSWR200715/109

Cabramatta

J Nguyen

Comment

NSWR200608/2

NSWR200715/110

Upper Hunter

A Ruff

Comment

NSWR200622/5

NSWR200715/111

Coogee, Heffron, Maroubra, Vaucluse

C Magee

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/112

Davidson

G Szabo - various signatories

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/113

Coogee

H Risseeuw

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/114

Riverstone

L Wallace - Riverstone NC and CAS

Comment

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/36

NSWR200715/115

Camden

G Davis - Camden Residents' Action Group

Comment

NSWR200630/26, NSWR200701/34,
NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/116

Cabramatta

M Lambert (Commenter has advised the Redistribution Panel that the comment is made in his personal capacity)

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/117

Cabramatta

M Lambert (Commenter has advised the Redistribution Panel that the comment is made in his personal capacity)

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/118

Cabramatta

A Lee

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/119

Ku-ring-gai, Wakehurst

C Patton

Comment

NSWR200630/27

NSWR200715/120

Ku-ring-gai, Wakehurst

R Patton, VP - Belrose Rural Community Association

Comment

NSWR200630/27

NSWR200715/121

Cabramatta

S Brown

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/122

Cabramatta

L Brown

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/123

Cabramatta

H Brown

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/124

Cabramatta

S Brown

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/125

Cabramatta

L Brown

Comment

NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/126

Kogarah, Miranda

P Williams

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/127 

Whole-of-State

Australian Labor Party (NSW Branch)

Comment
Bankstown map
Camden map
Campbelltown map
Cootamundra map
Goulbourn map
Monaro map
Villawood map

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/128 

Canterbury, Lakemba

B Coorey

Comment

NSWR200701/34, NSWR200701/39

NSWR200715/129 

Bega, Monaro

J Gaul

Comment

NSWR200701/34

NSWR200715/130 

Lismore, Northern Tablelands

J Marney

Document A
Document B
Document C

NSWR200628/10

NSWR200715/131 

Barwon, Lismore, Murray, New England, Tamworth & Upper Hunter

P Gill

Comment A
Comment B

NSW200701/35
NSW200701/38

NSWR200715/132 

Bathurst, Upper Hunter

M Suttor

Comment

NSWR200622/5

Mayoral Minute

Gunnedah, Tamworth

Councillor J Chaffey on behalf of Gunnedah Shire Council. This Mayoral Minute was lodged with the Redistribution Panel on behalf of Gunnedah Shire Council after the close of the comments period prescribed by the Electoral Act 2017. However, the Redistribution Panel has resolved to take into consideration the Mayoral Minute as the view of Gunnedah Shire Council and make it publicly available in the interests of transparency of the redistribution process.

Comment

Not specified

Correspondence

Newcastle, Wallsend

Newcastle City Council

This correspondence was received by the Redistribution Panel on behalf of Newcastle City Council after the close of the comments period prescribed by the Electoral Act 2017.  However, the Redistribution Panel has resolved to take into consideration the correspondence as the view of Newcastle City Council and make it publicly available in the interests of transparency of the redistribution process.

Comment

Not specified